Recently, a viewpoint has caused a stir in the financial circle. Howard Marks, the head of Oak Tree Capital, issued a bold statement: the so-called safe-haven value of gold is essentially a collective psychological game.



This seasoned investor managing hundreds of billions in assets candidly pointed out the fatal flaw of gold. First, gold generates no cash flow whatsoever. When you buy gold, you're just buying gold; it doesn't pay dividends like stocks or interest like bonds. So how is it priced? Entirely based on market sentiment—if everyone is bullish today, it rises; if the collective turns bearish tomorrow, it crashes.

Even more painfully, the so-called "store of value" narrative is fundamentally a self-fulfilling lie. If everyone believes gold is valuable, then it is temporarily valuable. But once that belief wavers... Marks used the metaphor of "The Emperor's New Clothes" to illustrate this phenomenon: everyone pretends to see the emperor's beautiful clothes, but in reality, there is nothing. History has long proven that during crises, gold still plunges.

In comparison, stocks and bonds have tangible cash flows that can be precisely valued, whereas gold is like a castle in the air—its value purely floating on the belief that "people believe in it."

Interestingly, despite the gold price rising another 7% by 2026, with central banks continuing to buy, and the shadow of geopolitical conflicts still lingering... Marks' warning is clear: those frenzies without intrinsic value will eventually fade away. When traditional "safe-haven" assets face a crisis of trust, a new narrative of value storage is emerging.

Institutional funds are rethinking their allocation strategies. US dollar, gold, or cryptocurrencies? Who is truly a reliable long-term store of value? This question is worth deep reflection.
View Original
This page may contain third-party content, which is provided for information purposes only (not representations/warranties) and should not be considered as an endorsement of its views by Gate, nor as financial or professional advice. See Disclaimer for details.
  • Reward
  • 6
  • Repost
  • Share
Comment
0/400
BearMarketSagevip
· 01-17 22:52
Max's words sound great, but the central bank is still frantically buying gold. What kind of show is this?
View OriginalReply0
FancyResearchLabvip
· 01-17 21:35
In theory, the logic that gold has no cash flow is sound, but in reality, central banks are still buying aggressively, which is outrageous. Essentially, it's still a zero-sum game.
View OriginalReply0
CommunityWorkervip
· 01-16 03:55
Gold is just a faith game, I've seen through it a long time ago. Max's words are really satisfying; Bitcoin at least has technical support.
View OriginalReply0
SleepyArbCatvip
· 01-16 03:50
Gold is just a faith-based market. Max said it quite harshly but he's not wrong... Is anyone still all-in on gold? I just don't want to think about it during nap time.
View OriginalReply0
BearMarketNoodlervip
· 01-16 03:45
Max is right, gold is just a faith game, but central banks are still buying. Isn't that the best irony?
View OriginalReply0
  • Pin