Shopify Stock (SHOP) Falls on AI Fears. Why I’m Bullish

Shopify SHOP +2.94% ▲ has come under pressure, with the stock down more than 20% year-to-date compared with the S&P 500’s (SPX) roughly 3% decline. Much of that weakness reflects investor concerns that artificial intelligence (AI) agents and large language models (LLMs) could reduce the relevance of one of the leading global omnichannel platforms that powers millions of merchants. I believe the opposite may happen, and AI is more likely to strengthen Shopify’s position as the transaction layer, merchant operating system, and checkout infrastructure across an expanding set of channels. This is why I’m bullish on SHOP.

Claim 70% Off TipRanks Premium

• Unlock hedge fund-level data and powerful investing tools for smarter, sharper decisions

• Stay ahead of the market with the latest news and analysis and maximize your portfolio’s potential

The Market Is Treating AI Like a Disruption Story

The bear case on Shopify has become familiar. If consumers increasingly shop through ChatGPT or other digital agents, some investors assume those platforms will own the customer relationship and reduce Shopify to a lower-value backend utility. That fear has helped drive a sharp re-rating in Shopify’s valuation. However, it also reflects a narrow view of what Shopify actually does.

Shopify has never just been a website builder. Its real value lies in helping merchants manage product catalogs, pricing, payments, checkout, inventory, and customer data across multiple channels. If AI becomes another major commerce surface, Shopify does not necessarily lose relevance. It may become even more important because merchants will need a single system that connects all those channels. That is exactly the role Shopify is trying to own.

Agentic Commerce Could Pull More Activity onto Shopify’s Rails

One reason I think the AI fear is overdone is that Shopify is already building for this shift rather than reacting to it late. The company recently introduced the Universal Commerce Protocol, developed with Google GOOGL +1.09% ▲ , to help AI agents move from product discovery to checkout while preserving merchant-specific catalogs, pricing, loyalty logic, and agentic storefronts.

In practical terms, that means merchants can plug into Shopify once and then distribute across multiple AI interfaces without rebuilding their commerce stack each time a new channel emerges. That model should sound familiar. Shopify previously benefited from the shift to mobile, social commerce, and other embedded channels by serving as the infrastructure layer behind them. Agentic commerce looks like the next version of that same opportunity.

Management has also made clear that transactions initiated through AI platforms still flow through Shopify’s backend system, including payments and checkout. So while the front-end discovery experience may evolve, the core economics do not automatically disappear.

Shopify’s Moat Is Bigger Than a Storefront

Another reason I remain constructive is that Shopify’s competitive advantage goes well beyond storefront software. Shopify already accounts for more than 14% of U.S. e-commerce, and some analysts expect the platform to support close to $600 billion in gross merchandise volume (GMV) by 2027. Together with Amazon AMZN +1.96% ▲ , Shopify has effectively established a duopoly in the U.S. e-commerce market, accounting for 50% of all U.S. e-commerce spend—one acting as the front-end portal for discovery, the other as the backend infrastructure for the independent web.

That scale gives Shopify one of the richest data environments in commerce. Product information, pricing, customer behavior, checkout activity, and merchant performance all feed into a single ecosystem. In an AI-driven world, context becomes critical. LLMs and AI agents work better when they draw on structured, trusted, and constantly updated product and merchant data. Shopify’s catalog tools, product network, and broader merchant stack give it an advantage that simple AI wrappers or no-code storefront tools are unlikely to replicate easily.

Shopify is no longer just a small and medium-sized business (SMB) story. Management has highlighted that merchants generating more than $25 million in GMV are among the fastest-growing cohorts on the platform, and B2B GMV growth has remained very strong. That suggests Shopify’s role is broadening rather than narrowing.

Payments and Checkout May Matter Even More

If there is one area where Shopify’s moat may prove especially durable, it is payments and checkout. Checkout looks simple from the outside, but at scale, it is hard. It requires speed, security, localization, fraud controls, flexible payment methods, and extremely high conversion performance. Shopify has spent years refining this layer, and that work is paying off.

In the latest quarter, Shopify Payments penetration reached 68% of GMV, up from 64% a year earlier. Shop Pay has also become one of the fastest checkout experiences in e-commerce, which matters directly because better checkout performance leads to lower cart abandonment and higher conversion for merchants.

That advantage should travel into AI commerce as well. If agentic shopping grows, merchants will still need trusted payment rails and a high-converting checkout process. Shopify appears well-positioned to provide both. The market seems too willing to assume that any AI company entering payments automatically weakens Shopify. In reality, it is far easier to sketch a payment flow than to build one that works at enterprise scale across geographies and channels.

Strong Fundamentals Make the Selloff Harder to Justify

The AI debate has also overshadowed the fact that Shopify’s underlying business remains very strong.

Management recently pointed to broad momentum across geographies, customer cohorts, enterprise, and products. First-quarter guidance called for low-30s percentage growth, which implies one of the company’s strongest growth periods in years. International markets remain a major contributor, and Europe has been especially strong.

At the same time, Shopify is showing good operating discipline. Management continues to target roughly flat headcount and has used AI internally to improve efficiency. Profitability has held up better than many feared, and the company’s $2 billion buyback authorization sends another signal that management remains confident in the model’s durability. That is not what a structurally disrupted platform usually looks like.

Wall Street’s View

According to TipRanks, Shopify carries a Strong Buy consensus rating, with 28 Buy, seven Hold, and zero Sell ratings. Based on 35 Wall Street analysts, the average price target is $164.08, implying about 29.6% upside from the recent share price of $126.58.

Conclusion

The market is treating AI as if it will make commerce platforms less important. I think Shopify may prove the opposite. As shopping expands beyond websites and apps into AI-driven discovery and agent-led transactions, merchants will need a stronger system of record for products, checkout, payments, and customer data. Shopify already occupies that role for millions of businesses.

AI may change how people discover products, but it does not eliminate the need for the infrastructure that actually completes the transaction. If anything, a more fragmented commerce landscape may make Shopify’s platform even more valuable.

That is why I remain bullish on Shopify. The stock’s decline reflects disruption fears, but AI’s rise may ultimately strengthen the very platform investors are worried about.

Disclaimer & DisclosureReport an Issue